Wednesday, 18 March 2015

Indian basketball: A dream gone sour !

The rigid stand of the Chief Executive Officer of the Basketball Federation of India (BFI), Roopam Sharma, has further strengthened the division of Indian basketball.
The blame is being pinned on the CEO, even though two parties are pulling the federation in two opposite directions, as it was she who has gone on to hijack the powers of the federation after it was agreed by the senior members of the federation to have the Annual General Meeting in Bengaluru on March 27.
Interestingly, there is a note prepared by the secretary general, Ajay Sud, in which all the eight officials, including the CEO and deputy CEO, Prem Pal, have signed, agreeing to the original venue and date.
President RS Gill, K. Govindaraj, Teja Singh Dhaliwal, Ajay Sud, Dr. DR Saini and Ashok Rangeen were the other members who were party to the decision taken at the meeting on February 26, in Delhi.
''The meeting was chaired by Sh. RS Gill, President, Basketball Federation of India. Sh. RS Gill requested all members present to work together to form a new body, for which elections are due in March 2015. After a detailed discussion, it was resolved that the meeting will be held at Bangaluru on 27th March 2015'', reads the note signed by the secretary general, which has been endorsed by all the eight senior members of BFI with their signature..
With two venues for the AGM in Bengaluru and Pune, on two dates March 27 and 28, there are two sets of documents, including the electoral college, which has caused considerable anguish in some quarters.
The electoral college, as published by the CEO on the BFI website has 62 names, whereas the one issued by the President has only 44. The rest of the names had apparently been sent only to the BFI office. Moreover, the president had restricted the nominations by the state units only to ''elected members of the respective association''.
Actually, the CEO has pleaded with the president in a letter dated March 11, seeking to correct the validity of nominations, requesting him to ''kindly circulate the revised notification in this regards to all affiliated units urgently''.
There is a strong communication from the general secretary of the Assam Basketball Association, Mukut Medhi, a vice president of BFI, written a week later, suggesting ''ulterior motive'' by the president and his ''cohorts''.
''Your arbitrary actions/decisions are bound to create friction among the members and divide BFI further. They are definitely not in the interest of BFI, nor the sport that we endeavour to promote. This also sends a wrong signal to our partners, IMG Reliance, who are the major source of our finance'', writes Medhi, in his letter to the president.
Well, the finance from IMG Reliance, to the tune of a few crore rupees every year, is already a dream gone sour for the players, even though millions are being spent in conducting the various national championships and national camps from the fund.
The former secretary general Harish Sharma for whom the post of CEO was formed after he had completed two terms, had announced the distribution of about 36 lakh rupees to the players, including juniors, and coaches, in January 2011. The graded payment with the leading players getting Rs.30,000 per month, the second line, Rs.20,000 and the juniors Rs.10,000 was awarded in retrospective effect from October 2010, during the presentation ceremony of the national championship in Delhi.
However, as one player put it succinctly, the payments to the players was stopped abruptly, ''when Harish Sharma was hospitalised''.
The much loved Harish who single-mindedly strove for the welfare of the players died of tuberculosis in brain in February 2012. His wife Roopam was requested, by the BFI president RS Gill and his team, to take charge of the post of CEO in March 2012. The steering committee's decision to draft her was ratified by the AGM then.
Roopam on her part, promised to uphold the high standards set by her husband in promoting the game, when she took charge as the CEO.
Much in contrast, months later, it was decided to abolish the posts of CEO and deputy CEO by the BFI, and part of the current power struggle has been triggered by such an attempt. The basic friction at this stage is caused by the move of the president to amend the Constitution of the federation, to bring it back to its original form.
Otherwise, it is difficult to fathom the reluctance of the CEO to take over the reins of the federation as the secretary general. In fact, the Gill faction has kept the post of secretary general still open for Roopam, even though she has other designs.
She may not take a salary from BFI, as Roopam is working in Indian Airlines, but it is felt that there is a lot of expenses on the CEO, running into a few lakh rupees every year, and the deputy CEO who is also paid a handsome salary apart from perks.
In trying to extend a strong support for Harish Sharma, the BFI had inadvertently bequeathed a lot of powers to the present CEO. If you ask for trouble, you invariably get it.
Even though the Union government has responded to the request of BFI for an observer for the election, ''to be held in Pune'', it has addressed the communication to the secretary general. The government generally deals only with the secretary general or the president. The position of CEO is a rare new phenomenon in some sports federations. Looking at the present development, the idea of CEO may not find much favour, owing to the considerable complications, even though it opens new avenues for people to hold on to power.
On the other hand, the Indian Olympic Association (IOA) has taken note of the meeting in Pune, and written back to the CEO, even though Gill and his team are persuading the concerned parties to realise that they alone have the Constitutional authority to conduct the AGM and the related meetings, in Bengaluru.
The plot should thicken soon, as it is almost time to finalise the nominations for various posts. It is surprising why nobody has taken the matter to court as yet.
Maybe, it is because Indian basketball has temporarily stopped being played on a court with distinct lines.
There is no doubt that Indian basketball is indeed a dream gone sour !

3 comments:

  1. Mr.Kamesh, I was wondering is your blog as uninformed as you are? or has it got a sixth sense that whenever I try posting something which counters your incorrect reporting as a journalist, it reads into it and doesn't post it?
    I was wanting to know if you've seen the copy of the letter so signed by the CEO/Dy CEO agreeing to Bangalore as the venue of the AGM?

    Also, I'm sure you are aware the federation cup is happening in Pune, So are you/the president going to pay from their pockets for travel expenses of the body to fly from the federation cup to the voting venue in bangalore and back? and while this is happening who is going to manage the tournament when the essential key office people are going to be tucked away in bangalore voting?
    Whats the problem with having elections in PUNE, when the whole team of the BFI will be there?
    Im sure since you're following only one side of the issue, you must have not seen the letter of Mr. Sud ( secy general) stating the venue to be PUNE, but conveniently sending a resignation, a few days later.
    Have you read the constitution of the BFI? I'm sure you must have since you already know so much, Please enlighten me on the procedure to be followed when an office bearer resigns? Does the constitution say the powers are to be given to the President? I'm sure you know what constitutional violations are?
    When a federation has 32 voting bodies, if my facts are correct, then how does the voting rights of 10 bodies be taken away without a reason? From what I infer, its clear demarcation of the North East states not being allowed to vote. Regional divide? isn't that what our country is trying to fight, But looks like they are violating Article 14 of the Indian Constitution. Im sure you know what that is?
    What happens to Railways and Maharashtra? on what grounds are they not allowed to vote, clearly 1/3 of the electorate is cut, for what joy? and if that happens how can the so called election with on 22 states voting be fair?
    I wonder during all this what is the role of the IOA and the Ministry of Sports, Since your blog says the IOA has recognized the Pune election, are you telling me the Ministry and the IOA are fools for following the right procedure? Im sure you're implying that.
    Once again let me counter your claims of LAKHS BEING SPENT on the CEO and THE DY CEO, you must have seen the accounts of the BFI and if you have that is clear violation because books of accounts are not open for inspection to any PUBLIC, you know the law right? however, LAKHS BEING SPENT ON WHAT? the CEO draws no salary, the flight expenditure of the CEO is AIR INDIA, and she does not use the federation funds to travel unlike other office bearers who travel along with family members.
    Mr. Kamesh, please enlighten me again on where did you get your facts from? I understand its a blog and blogs are personal views and reporting, but then again you aren't writing a fashion/makeup blog where you can write whatever suits your whims and fancies?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you Yashaswika for the comments. It is a good thing that there is scope for quick and detailed response in this forum, unlike the laborious and restricted process in a newspaper. In fact, my own reply vanished when I tried to post. It has happened in the past as well, even when I have tried to post favourable comments.

    The media is only watching from outside. It has no stakes. Why blame the mirror when the house is not in order. Fortunately, or unfortunately, the media has no time or space for Indian basketball at the moment. If India wins the Cricket World Cup in Australia, the media will not bother about Indian basketball for the next few months.

    Anyway, coming to the point, how does it matter if the other faction has only 40-odd eligible voters, when Pune AGM has full 62, especially so when the Bengaluru meeting is not even legally correct ! Wish it was as simple as economy of travel. The facts are in front of everyone concerned. So, it is no big deal, knowing them.

    Moreover, the Sports Ministry has been pleading with the Sports Federations to put their accounts on their website. They are not supposed to be secret. For arugment sake, it is good journalism, if I know things that I am not supposed to know. But, am not guilty on that count!

    On another count, less said about the IOA and the government, the better.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your Blog is very organized and a Transparent and an effective platform for a sports person and sports Authorities as well..... It is a good thing that there is scope for quick and detailed response in this forum, You said
    "the media is only watching from outside. ....It has no stakes".....is 100 % true Kamesh Sir.... and also you said a wonderfull Quote "Why blame the mirror when the house is not in order". I'll also say a locally popular Quote that "NAACH NA AAWE ANGAN TEDHA". I'm fully agreed with your Article.
    You said amazing that......."the Sports Ministry has been pleading with the Sports Federations to put their accounts on their website... They are not supposed to be secret". it is good journalism and a effort of Brave Journlist as you Kamesh Sir, Even Kamesh Sir.... We should keep away Civil servants and politicians too from the Department of Game and the Sports Authority of India....They just fill their own pockets and Bank Balance....All People have been entered in Sports Authority are corrupt....We need to do their "Sting Operations" and expose them....through active and revolutinary Journalism..... Jai Hind

    ReplyDelete